Dry vs. Wet pet food pellet Extruder: Cost Differences in Feed Pelletizer Investment and Operation

In terms of initial investment, dry extruders have a clear advantage. For the same capacity, dry extruders are 20%-40% cheaper than wet extruders: a dry extruder with an hourly capacity of 500 kg costs approximately 50,000 yuan, while a wet extruder with the same capacity costs 70,000-80,000 yuan. The difference is even greater when supporting equipment is included—wet extruders require a steam generator (10,000-20,000 yuan) and a dedicated dryer (30,000-50,000 yuan), making the initial investment for a complete wet extrusion production line 60%-80% higher than that of a dry extruder. For small producers with limited funds, the lower barrier to entry of dry extruders makes them more accessible and allows for faster production.

Regarding operating costs, both have their advantages and disadvantages, requiring a comprehensive assessment based on production volume. In terms of energy consumption, dry extruders rely on frictional heat generation, resulting in 15%-20% higher electricity consumption per unit product compared to wet extruders (120-150 kWh for dry extruders and 100-120 kWh for wet extruders per ton of feed). However, wet extruders require steam. Using an electric steam generator adds an extra 50-80 kWh per ton of feed; using a coal-fired or gas-fired steam generator incurs additional fuel costs. Based on a monthly feed production of 20 tons and an electricity cost of 0.8 yuan/kWh, the monthly electricity cost for dry extruders is approximately 2400-3000 yuan, while for wet extruders (electrically heated steam) it is approximately 2800-3680 yuan, making dry extruders more energy-efficient.

In terms of labor and maintenance costs, wet extruders offer greater advantages in terms of economies of scale. Dry extruders are relatively simple to operate, but require high precision in controlling the moisture content of raw materials, necessitating dedicated personnel for real-time monitoring and adjustment; a single production line requires 2-3 people. Wet extruders, while involving more equipment, are highly automated, with water, steam, and extrusion parameters controlled via a PLC system; a single production line requires only 1-2 people. In terms of maintenance, the screw in a dry extruder experiences more friction, resulting in a 30% shorter lifespan compared to a wet extruder (dry screws can last 1-2 years, wet screws 2-3 years). The screw wear cost per ton of feed is 0.5-1 yuan higher for dry extruders than wet extruders. However, for monthly production exceeding 50 tons, the labor and maintenance cost advantages of wet extruders become increasingly apparent, saving 1000-2000 yuan per month.

The cost of finished product loss is also significant. Dry extruders have poor puffing stability, resulting in a finished product defect rate of approximately 5%-8%; wet extruders have a defect rate of only 2%-3%. Based on a feed cost of 8,000 yuan per ton, a dry extruder incurs a loss of 800-1,600 yuan more than a wet extruder when producing 20 tons per month. Overall, dry extruders have lower total costs for small-scale production (monthly output < 10 tons); for medium-to-large-scale production (monthly output ≥ 10 tons), wet extruders have a more significant long-term operating cost advantage, and the cost difference can usually cover the initial equipment price difference after six months of production.

About Us

Customer visit

Certificate of Honor